Skip to main content
Friday, November 13, 2026Nov 13

The auto industry was warned: Battery recycling was poisoning people

FILE — Workers at a battery-breaking yard in Lagos, Nigeria, load dead car batteries to be recycled on April 23, 2025. Despite decades of evidence on the toxic effects of lead battery recycling, companies opted not to act and blocked efforts to clean up the industry. (Finbarr O’Reilly/The New York Times)
FILE — Workers at a battery-breaking yard in Lagos, Nigeria, load dead car batteries to be recycled on April 23, 2025. Despite decades of evidence on the toxic effects of lead battery recycling, companies opted not to act and blocked efforts to clean up the industry. (Finbarr O’Reilly/The New York Times)

At Ford Motor Co. headquarters near Detroit, Phillip Toyne, a shy Australian lawyer, warned executives in 2005 that the lead inside car batteries was poisoning people.

Lead is an essential, but toxic, element of car batteries. As demand rose, the auto industry increased its use of recycled lead. But many recycling factories around the world were pumping toxic smoke into communities.

Toyne, records show, pitched a solution: a program in which inspectors would certify factories that operated cleanly. Car manufacturers and battery makers could then market themselves as buying only from environmentally friendly suppliers.

It went nowhere.

An investigation by The New York Times and The Examination showed that African factories have poisoned people while recycling lead to be sold to U.S. companies. Children near one cluster of factories outside Lagos, Nigeria, had lead in their blood at levels that could cause lifelong brain damage, according to testing commissioned as part of the investigation.