Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Times Opinion: The GOP is kidding itself about the economy

Photo by Win McNamee via Getty Images/TNS / U.S. President Donald Trump displays a chart with economic data in the Oval Office on Aug. 7, 2025, in Washington, D.C.
Photo by Win McNamee via Getty Images/TNS / U.S. President Donald Trump displays a chart with economic data in the Oval Office on Aug. 7, 2025, in Washington, D.C.

No amount of narrative-setting can convince American voters that the economy is better or worse than their own experience dictates. That’s what I’ve been telling the Republicans who’ve asked me, earnestly, if the media’s reporting on affordability is responsible for voters’ gloomy assessment of their finances.

That’s not to say that the news media (guilty as charged) doesn’t get caught up in narrative-setting from time to time. It’s our job to report on the state of the economy, domestically and globally. We rely on statistics, percentages, figures and graphs, and the performance of stock and bond markets, to fulfill that function. If the macro indicators appear to be singing from the same hymnal, well then, voilà, a cohesive media narrative on current economic conditions.

But of course, the economy is about more than numbers. It’s about how American voters feel about it and experience it. Do they feel anxious or secure? Like they’re getting ahead or treading water? Financially stretched or making ends meet?

As the 2024 elections approached, with first President Joe Biden running for a second term and then Vice President Kamala Harris succeeding him atop the Democratic ticket, the American economy was strong and growing. Inflation, the acute source of voters’ economic anxiety, was cooling. That’s what the numbers told us, and the numbers were largely correct (although we learned this year that the jobs market was weaker than presumed). And so, the breadth of the media’s reporting on the health of the economy reflected as much.

But voters felt differently.