The Alabama Court of Civil Appeals upheld a lower court’s dismissal of a lawsuit that alleged inmates were being forced to labor in involuntary servitude in violation of the state constitution.
The three plaintiffs, incarcerated by the Alabama Department of Corrections, said in the lawsuit that they were assigned additional work duties without pay and lost phone and canteen access, visitation hours and good-time credits, while receiving unfavorable disciplinary reports.
The appeals court Friday affirmed the Montgomery Circuit Court’s decision, which found the court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction to decide the issue and that the people incarcerated lacked standing to file the complaint because they have not accrued any correctional incentive time that they could lose.
“None of the other punishments the prisoners alleged,” the ruling said, “constitute involuntary servitude because they do not involve the use of physical coercion, the threat of physical coercion or the use of or the threat of coercion through law or the legal process.”
Attorneys for the plaintiffs criticized the decision.
