Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Toni Says: The cost of my Medicare supplement has exploded. What can I do?

Toni,

When I first enrolled in Medicare in 2019, I picked Medicare supplement Plan F. In February of 2024 I was approached by a telemarketer on my cell phone who talked me into a Medicare supplement Plan K because this plan had lower premiums than Plan F. I could change because I was in good health at that time.

In March 2025, I was hospitalized due to cardiac issues because I passed out in the doctor’s office. Now I am having serious heart problems, causing me to need a heart transplant.

Since I have Plan K, I must pay the deductible plus 50% cost until I meet the Medicare supplement’s maximum out of pocket, and for 2026 the cost has exploded to $8,000. I tried to go back to Plan F, but the agent said I couldn’t because of my heart issue.

I thought with Medicare, preexisting conditions did not count. Can you help me to understand this? Your assistance would be appreciated. Thanks, Toni.