General Motors, American Airlines, Texaco, Caesars Entertainment all have something in common. They and hundreds of other familiar companies were once broke and on the verge of extinction but lived to fight another day thanks to the American legal framework for bankruptcy.
Roughly half of all new business ventures fail within their first five years, erasing the shareholders’ equity investment and often leaving the enterprise with debt it cannot repay. Even established enterprises with long histories may encounter existential challenges due to economic cycles, external events or management mistakes. But who would willingly undertake such risk if the result of failure was a lifetime of penury or even imprisonment? Part of the genius of the American system is the recognition that risk-taking must be encouraged and failure is not a death sentence.
This spirit of entrepreneurship propelled us from colonial outpost to the world’s superpower. Capitalism depends upon the competitive allocation of capital to its best and highest use, a process that Adam Smith referred to as the “invisible hand.”
Yet this phenomenal success would not have been possible had the framers not anticipated the need for an orderly discharge of debts in circumstances where the debtor had no hope of repayment.
Article I of the Constitution grants Congress the authority to establish uniform laws governing bankruptcies, intended to replace a pastiche of disparate state statutes. Within a document so remarkable in every aspect, the doctrine of corporate bankruptcy ranks high for its salutary effect on the development of capitalism in the New World.
