Among the few things that Americans agree on these days is that housing is too expensive. With a shortfall of at least 3.7 million homes, the obvious solution is to build more. Regrettably, a once-promising effort in Congress intended to do just that now seems to be falling apart — a victim of populist politics gone awry.
Over the past two decades, home values have risen faster than incomes in much of the U.S. Rents have also soared in many cities. The main culprits are restrictive local zoning and land-use rules, which curb construction and investment. When cities ease such regulations to meet pent-up demand, the effect on prices is often dramatic.
Enter the ROAD to Housing Act, which recently passed the U.S. Senate. It creates a variety of incentives for communities to overhaul zoning and boost development, attempts to streamline environmental permitting and eliminates a rule that limits the availability of cheaper manufactured homes. All worthwhile.
Yet, as so often in Washington, the bill won support for these measures by stitching together a tangle of other ideas, many of them bad. One recent addition is particularly counterproductive. Claiming to protect Main Street homebuyers from undue Wall Street competition, it would ban most home purchases by large institutional investors.
Although this stipulation may please populists, it would be foolish for several reasons. For one, the alarm about private equity firms and hedge funds outbidding potential homebuyers is misplaced: Big institutional investors own only about 1% of the single-family market, and there’s little evidence that they’ve significantly increased costs even in areas where their ownership is most concentrated.
