A year ago, we endorsed a challenger to Chattanooga City Council member Marvene Noel in the City Council election because we believed the challenger would be a better representative for all parts of the district, would ask the hard questions and would communicate better with her constituents.
The fact that Noel, representing Orchard Knob, drew three challengers in her first bid for a full term indicated to us some dissatisfaction with her service. Nevertheless, she won the chance to remain in her seat in a runoff.
Then, in August, when several council members, reflecting the wishes of their constituents, sought compromises to Chattanooga Mayor Tim Kelly’s proposed property tax increase, Noel said one of the compromise proposals had “racist overtones.”
As we said in August, introducing such language stopped healthy debate. As it nearly always does.
In the end, Kelly got the full tax increase he sought, but Noel’s back-and-forth exchange with council member Jenny Hill, who had made the compromise proposal in good faith, was troubling.
