Skip to main content
Tuesday, November 17, 2026Nov 17

Movie Review: In ‘The Sheep Detectives,’ the private eyes have wool over their eyes

This image released by Amazon MGM Studios shows sheep character Lily, voiced Julia-Louis Dreyfus, left, with Hugh Jackman as George Hardy, in a scene from "The Sheep Detectives." (Amazon MGM Studios via AP)
This image released by Amazon MGM Studios shows sheep character Lily, voiced Julia-Louis Dreyfus, left, with Hugh Jackman as George Hardy, in a scene from "The Sheep Detectives." (Amazon MGM Studios via AP)

Maybe out of fear of putting filmgoers to sleep, the sheep has not been much of a mainstay at the movies.

There’s Charles Burnett’s lyrical classic “Killer of Sheep.” You could get creative and cite Chris Farley’s “Black Sheep.” But, really, this is the domain of “Shaun the Sheep,” the uber-charming Aardman Animation about the wordless but wise guardian of Mossy Bottom Farm.

Joining this small flock of films now is “The Sheep Detectives,” which, like “Shaun the Sheep,” takes place in the verdant English countryside and concerns barnyard animals with higher-than-usual IQs. Every night, shepherd George Hardy (Hugh Jackman) reads murder mysteries as bedtime stories for his hillside of grass grazers. They listen intently and bleat the bad guys. Only while talking amongst themselves afterward do they reveal their hidden powers of deduction.

So when George turns up dead, the sheep are on the case. Led by the particularly keen Lily (voiced by Julia Louis-Dreyfus), they prove remarkably adept private eyes despite the wool over their eyes.

But if such an ewe-dunit premise has you expecting a lightly funny caper, “The Sheep Detectives” is too gentle and strenuously poignant to turn its silly tale into all that much fun. As devoid as I was previously of opinions on sheep detective movies, I do think they ought to be funny. There are undoubtedly a few decent gags here — the cleverest trick is to make the MGM lion baa, not roar, at the start — but “The Sheep Detectives” is too mild to stand out from the herd of mysteries, even as a strictly family-friendly variety.