Four out of five households that purchase a new vehicle finance the transaction. But thanks to the sharp increase in car prices and interest rates since 2020, more consumers are falling into a debt trap as they trade in cars worth less than their outstanding loans.
Nearly a third of U.S. consumers who traded in a vehicle in the first quarter are underwater, according to automotive research firm Edmunds, carrying an average $7,183 in negative equity into the new loan, up 42% compared with the same quarter of 2021. The average amount financed, as well as the typical monthly payment, also reached new record highs.
Negative equity can compound financial stress in a self-reinforcing loop. While the average monthly payment on a new vehicle is $773 over 70 months, upside-down buyers on average paid $159 more per month, and more than 40% of those loans extended to 84 months and often carried higher interest rates, further exacerbating the pain. So, how did we get here, and how can we break the cycle?
The concept of “buying on time” goes back to the early 19th century. In 1807, a New York furniture firm named Cowperthwaite & Co. established a credit contract allowing customers to finance furniture purchases. As mass production picked up speed, consumers were offered terms on such varied goods as carriages, farm equipment, stoves and even pianos (though now you can’t give one away). The Singer Sewing Machine Co. introduced its “dollar down, dollar a week” plan in 1850, and in 1905, the Spiegel company offered financing for every item in its new mail-order catalog.
The first mass-produced passenger car, the Model T, was rolled out to the public by Henry Ford of Dearborn, Michigan, in 1908. Although Ford’s thesis was to keep costs low to promote affordability, Henry Ford himself was an ardent foe of credit and refused to offer financing. Despite its reasonable cost of $825 (around $25,000 in today’s dollars), many consumers were still priced out. Several enterprising dealers had begun experimenting in 1909 with car loans that were then sold to independent finance companies, but the old man remained steadfast.
