WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Thursday backed the Federal Communications Commission’s power to enforce its rules that protect consumer privacy, combat robocalls and regulate broadcasting, a decision with implications for the government’s ability to protect consumers and the public more broadly.
Two major cellphone carriers, Verizon and AT&T, were fined millions of dollars by the agency as punishment for what the FCC said was their failure to protect customer data. The companies sued, saying those fines violated their rights because they were assessed without a trial, in a case that eventually landed before the Supreme Court.
In its 8-1 decision Thursday, the Supreme Court said the companies’ Seventh Amendment rights were not violated. While the FCC imposed millions of dollars in fines, the companies could have challenged them by refusing to pay and then proceeding to a jury trial in federal court, which the Supreme Court said was sufficient to protect their rights.
The FCC orders “did not create an obligation to pay,” Chief Justice John Roberts wrote. He said the companies were not “impermissibly coerced” into giving up their right to a trial because before a party “can be made to pay, the jury gets the last word.”
Justice Clarence Thomas dissented, saying he would have sided with Verizon and AT&T.
