Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Free Press Opinion: Turns out, Bush was right on Social Security

Zimmytws/Dreamstime/TNS / As Social Security hurtles toward insolvency, the costs of choosing demagoguery over substance are high.
Zimmytws/Dreamstime/TNS / As Social Security hurtles toward insolvency, the costs of choosing demagoguery over substance are high.

As Social Security hurtles toward insolvency, its path is a reflection of missed opportunity. In particular, many Democrats over the years have preferred performance demagoguery designed to score political points over the difficult task of finding solutions that actually address the system’s long-term structural deficiencies.

A case in point was President George W. Bush’s Social Security reform plan in the early 2000s.

Bush’s proposal, offered at a time when the Trust Fund was running surpluses, included “progressive price indexing,” which would have slowed annual benefit increases for those with higher benefits, and a proposal to allow individuals to invest a tiny portion of their contributions into personal accounts.

Democrats went apoplectic. Nevada’s Harry Reid and his cohorts began harping on the proposal as a “risky scheme,” claiming it would result in lost benefits. History hasn’t been kind to this analysis.

The Wall Street Journal noted last week that, had Bush’s reform become law — it never got a vote in Congress — workers would have benefited handsomely. If an employee beginning in 2011 “had invested $83 per month in an S&P index fund and reinvested dividends, the account would have grown to some $55,000 by now.”