Read the Supreme Court’s recent ruling on transgender athletes — the majority’s decision, written by Justice Brett Kavanaugh, and the dissent, written by Justice Sonia Sotomayor — and you will see the court arguing about something more fundamental than the law. They are arguing about who should be seen, whose story ought to be heard and who deserves to be protected.
Kavanaugh’s opinion contains a long lyrical tribute to female athletes. “They spend extraordinary time and effort to train in the heat and in the cold, to work out early in the morning and late at night, to get a little faster, to become a little stronger, to jump a little higher, to shoot a little better, to watch a little more video, to make the lonely journey back from an ACL tear, to scrap for playing time, to start, to win the game, to win a championship,” he writes.
Sotomayor’s dissent, too, includes a description of a young person in love with her sport. Referring to a plaintiff by her initials, Sotomayor writes, “B.P.J.’s mother reports that B.P.J. ‘has had the time of her life participating on these teams.’ She has watched B.P.J. make close friends and gain a sense of belonging. Her mother recalls taking B.P.J. to practice after hours and on weekends, and often witnessing B.P.J. practicing her form in the backyard ‘by herself, for hours.’ Above all, her mother explains that B.P.J. ‘is the happiest I have ever seen her when she is accepted for who she is and able to participate in school sports.'”
Kavanaugh and Sotomayor are looking at different athletes: He is describing cisgender girls, and Sotomayor is focusing on one of the plaintiffs in the case, a West Virginia high school student named Becky Pepper-Jackson who was excluded from middle school sports after her state enacted legislation banning trans girls in girls’ sports. (When a district court found West Virginia’s law to be probably unconstitutional, Pepper-Jackson joined her school’s track and cross-country teams.)
Kavanaugh’s argument stresses that everyone deserves to compete on a level playing field. People assigned male at birth have an inherent physical advantage, he writes; they are, on average, taller, bigger, faster and stronger than people assigned female at birth. Making members of these two groups compete with each other is unfair. Pepper-Jackson can join the boys’ team or not participate at all.
