Skip to main content
Sunday, November 15, 2026Nov 15

Ohio lawsuit alleges NCAA unfairly denying some athletes a fifth season

The NCAA Division I Cabinet approved a monumental change in eligibility rules Tuesday. (AP File Photo/Matt Slocum)
The NCAA Division I Cabinet approved a monumental change in eligibility rules Tuesday. (AP File Photo/Matt Slocum)

Less than 24 hours after the NCAA Division I Cabinet approved a monumental change in eligibility rules, a group of 15 college basketball players filed a lawsuit in an Ohio state court claiming the new age-based model unfairly shuts them out of further competition.

The NCAA will now allow athletes five seasons of competition over a five-year period that begins with their full-time enrollment at a D-I member school or the academic year after their 19th birthday, whichever occurs first. The move will all but eliminate waivers or redshirt years for extended eligibility except for religious missions, pregnancy or active-duty military service. No longer will extensions be considered for athletes who are injured.

Athletes whose eligibility expired by spring 2026 under the traditional model — four seasons of competition within five years — will not be allowed a fifth year of competition under the new rules that go into effect this fall.

The lawsuit filed Wednesday in Cincinnati and Hamilton County sought temporary and permanent injunctive relief that would allow a fifth year of competition for athletes who graduated from high school in 2022 and began their college sports careers that fall and never redshirted. A judge denied a temporary restraining order hours after the lawsuit was filed and scheduled a hearing for next Wednesday on the request for a preliminary injunction.

The new eligibility rule “unjustifiably restrains their ability to earn money through use of their name, image, and likeness (‘NIL’) connected to their work as Division I athletes,” attorneys Ryan Downton and Charles Rittgers wrote in the complaint.