The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit ruled in favor of Tennessee on Monday, rejecting Kalshi’s claim that federal commodities law exempts its sports bets from Tennessee’s laws. Kalshi is an online company offering sports bets without a Tennessee license. This decision lifts an order that previously blocked the State from enforcing those laws against the company.
Kalshi argued that the company isn’t a sportsbook; they are a sophisticated financial exchange. Instead of betting on a football game, their users were buying “event contracts” — financial instruments designed to hedge risk. Under this logic, Kalshi answered only to Washington’s federal regulators at the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), far out of reach from local state authorities.
Tennessee state regulators and Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti saw things differently. To them, it looked like a bet, paid out like a bet, and was placed on a Saturday afternoon kickoff. Tennessee officials argued that Kalshi was simply running an unlicensed sportsbook, bypassing the Tennessee Sports Wagering Council, dodging state taxes, and ignoring consumer protection laws meant to govern local wagering.
“This is a great win for Tennessee. Kalshi attempted an end run around Tennessee law to avoid any of the rules or taxes associated with sports gambling. They failed,” Skrmett said through a release. “Sports wagering is heavily regulated because it can do a lot of harm, and I’m glad we thwarted Kalshi’s efforts to remove every safeguard and put Tennessee sports bettors at risk. I’m proud of our outstanding team for defending Tennessee’s right to set its own rules.”
The clash sets up a high-stakes showdown over who truly controls the booming world of prediction markets. Kalshi leaned heavily on the federal Commodity Exchange Act, claiming that federal law preempted individual state police powers. Tennessee stood firm, asserting its historic right to regulate gambling within its own borders to protect its citizens.
