Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Tennessee court rules secret recording not child pornography

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) – The Tennessee Supreme Court has ruled that a man who hid a video camera in the bedroom of a 13-year-old relative while she was in the shower is not guilty of attempting to produce child pornography.

In a split decision filed earlier this week, the court’s three female judges found David Scott Hall’s actions did not meet Tennessee’s definition for production of child pornography, which requires sexual content beyond mere nudity.

According to the an account of events in court filings, Hall briefly lived with a relative and her two young daughters in May 2010 when he was helping the family repair their flood-damaged home. One morning when the 13-year-old was in the shower, Hall hid a camera on top of her dresser under some clothes.

The girl returned from the shower in casual clothes, noticed the red light of the camera almost immediately and grabbed it, taking it to her mother. Hall was 50 at the time.

At a bench trial in 2015, a Nashville judge found Hall guilty of attempted especially aggravated sexual exploitation of a minor. He was sentenced to serve 12 months of a four-year sentence, according to the Attorney General’s Office, and also received four years of probation. The Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals upheld the trial court’s decision. However, the Supreme Court’s ruling Monday overturns Hall’s conviction.