Prosecutors believe a woman who sat on a jury for a Chattooga County, Ga., man’s murder trial last week knew the accused killer and could have influenced the hung jury.
But several jurors and the defense attorney for William Bob Packer said the jury was unable to decide whether Packer acted in self-defense or purposefully killed James “Pee Wee” Kirby in 2010 because police botched the investigation.
The weeklong trial for Packer, accused of shooting his neighbor and friend, ended Friday in a mistrial after jurors agreed unanimously to drop a felony murder charge. But jurors were split on the malice murder and aggravated assault charges, with eight “not guilty” to four “guilty” votes.
Chris Arnt, Lookout Mountain Judicial Circuit assistant district attorney, said he discovered after the trial that one female juror didn’t mention in questioning that she knew the defendant and discussed matters that weren’t presented during the trial with other jurors.
But several jurors said that wasn’t true. They said they were conflicted because of the lack of evidence and wondered why lead investigator Kandy Dodd didn’t testify at trial.
