Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Fight the fright stampede

With the leading Republican aspirant for the presidency, Rick Perry, denouncing Social Security as a “Ponzi scheme,” and the “gang of six” U.S. senators on the national debt commission considering harsh downsizing of Social Security and Medicare, Sen. Bernie Sanders’ solid proposal for keeping Social Security in the black for another 75 years comes as a breath of fresh sanity against the GOP fright agenda. His proposal: eliminate the cap on income for Social Security payroll taxes.

Except for the misguided political opposition of Republicans, that wouldn’t be hard to accomplish. A positive vote in the House and Senate on a bill to remove the cap would do the trick. President Obama surely would approve. Though he hasn’t advocated it lately, he proposed the same thing in his 2008 campaign.

The present salary cap for Social Security tax deductions is $106,800. Earnings above that level are exempt from the Social Security payroll tax. That means that all but a few percent of America workers and households pay Social Security taxes on 100 percent of their income (the nation’s media household income dropped in 2010 to $49,445), while multi-billionaires like Warren Buffet pay Social Security taxes on less than 1 percent of their income.

Buffett himself understands the vast wealth gap and tax inequity between ordinary Americans and the super-rich that is hollowing out America’s middle class while concentrating ever higher proportions of the nation’s wealth in the hands of the top tenth of the top 1 percent of households. Indeed, he has become a strong vocal advocate of raising taxes on the ultra-wealthy back to at least the Reagan-era rates to mitigate the imbalance, bring down the federal debt and strengthen the economy.

In the broad moral view of social equity, the income-cap for Social Security payroll taxes and the vast disparity of burden sharing avoided by the ultra-wealthy for tax equity generally is indisputably unfair. The mechanics of wealth formation in America and other industrialized nations’ economies spring from the common tax base for infrastructure and the productivity and labor generated by the nation’s broad and overburdened middle class. It’s only fair to tax the ultra-wealthy proportionally relative to the higher tax rates paid by working Americans across the board.