I’ve watched the NCAA tournament every year since 1966. I’ve covered it every year since 1983. Not once in all that time as a sports fan, sports writer or both have I ever seen a more bizarre or justifiable ending than Butler’s stunning 71-70 victory over Pittsburgh on Saturday evening.
If you missed it, this is basically what happened: Having taken a one-point lead with 2.2 seconds to go, the Bulldogs were shocked to see a foul called on Butler guard Shelvin Mack with 1.4 to play.
It can long be debated whether a foul should have been called on Mack 45 feet from the basket as he and the Panthers’ Gilbert Brown fought to gain possession of a half-court pass to Brown. There is no debate that Mack never should have been close enough to Brown to foul him.
But the foul was called and Brown went to the line with a chance to win it for Pitt, the No. 1 seed in the Southeast Regional. Befitting a player who had scored 24 points before that foul, Brown drilled the first free throw to tie the game at 70.
Befitting one of the best games of the tournament, he missed the second, which should have brought about the tournament’s second overtime game in an hour, San Diego State having outlasted Temple in double-overtime earlier in the evening.