Skip to main content
Sunday, November 15, 2026Nov 15

What states have the most expensive rental insurance?

Renters insurance tile / photo courtesy of Getty Images
Renters insurance tile / photo courtesy of Getty Images

Only about 37% of renters regularly buy renters insurance, compared to the 95% of homeowners who buy insurance on their home, according to the Insurance Information Institute. For a typical 2-bedroom apartment, the average American renter pays $180 a year, but rates are higher in the South due primarily to higher property crime rates and weather-related damages. What states have the least affordable renters insurance?

1. Mississippi, $258 a year with a mean monthly rent of $812.

2. Oklahoma, $236 a year with a mean monthly rent of $778.

3. Louisiana, $235 a year with mean monthly rent of $883

4. Alabama, 235 a year with mean monthly rent of $835