PDF: Judge Don Poole’s Memorandum and Order
The mother of a dead child is set to go on trial in November for aggravated neglect, exactly two years and three days after a Hamilton County jury acquitted her ex-boyfriend of first-degree murder in the child’s death.
No one in that time has been held accountable for the death of Sierra Carpenter, who was 18 months old in 2006 when she died of blunt force trauma to the head.
Prosecutors were adamant that the culprit was Brian Rutherford, the ex-boyfriend of Sierra’s mother, Traci Carpenter, but his acquittal came after witness testimony indicated that Ms. Carpenter’s actions might have contributed to Sierra’s death.
While prosecutors have declined to charge Ms. Carpenter with any crime involving homicide — she is charged only with one count of aggravated child neglect — Sierra’s paternal grandparents said Monday that they feel they have achieved the goal of seeing her face a jury trial as Mr. Rutherford did.