A judge overseeing a hearing on The Pet Company animal cruelty case said today he doubts the City Court has jurisdiction over the store’s license or restitution questions.
Judge Don Harris told attorneys for McKamey and the store this morning that, as he understands the Chattanooga city charter, city courts only settle violations of city code and hear misdemeanor cases when defendants waive their jury trial rights.
“It’s not really clear in the code who has the right to revoke the permits,” he said.
On June 15, the store was cited to City Court and given a warrant revoking its license to sell or keep animals based on complaints and findings of neglect and sanitary problems at the Hamilton Place store. More than 60 pets were seized from the store and handed over to McKamey Animal Care and Adoption Center.
City Judge Sherry Paty oversaw the case until July 26, when she declared a mistrial and recused herself from the case. Paty cited a July 1 e-mail from Mayor Ron Littlefield urging her to not “leave McKamey holding the bag” for about $40,000 in expenses related to the case.