Skip to main content
Saturday, November 14, 2026Nov 14

The Gulf isn’t safe yet

A mericans have good reason to be perplexed by the contrary assessments of how much oil remains from BP’s 5 million barrel spill in the Gulf of Mexico. That’s a problem not just for voters, but also for Republicans and the Obama administration, which recently touted success in cleanup efforts while happily claiming that most Gulf fishing grounds were once again open and providing safe seafood.

The president’s buoyant statements came after the federal National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administrated announced earlier this month that roughly three-quarters of the spilled oil had disappeared – eaten my microbes, burned, skimmed, evaporated or dissipated beyond recognition or hazard. NOAA’s estimate left just a quarter of the oil to be accounted for. And much of that, it said, lay in oiled beaches, fisheries and sediment, as well as in some areas of surface water.

Then came the counter-views. An expert team of scientists from the University of Georgia and Georgia Sea Grant released a study last week which said that roughly same amount of oil that the government said had disappeared was, in fact, still around. The Georgia groups said 70 percent to 79 percent of the spilled oil could be found largely in a vast undersea plume in a deep canyon, where it still posed a significant near-term and possibly long-term threat to the ecological health of the Gulf’s sea life and ecosystem.

Researchers at the University of South Florida followed the Georgia groups’ studies with their finding that dispersants may have caused a mass of tiny globules of oil to descend to the ocean floor and settle in the bottom of a deep canyon some 40 miles off the coast of the Florida panhandle.

Another scientific research project, led by Dr. Richard Camilli of the esteemed Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution and reported by the journal Science last week, said it also had found a large, deep plume of oil which was dissipating slowly and could continue to threaten gulf fisheries for months or years to come.