Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Age bias case puts spotlight on police policies

Two months before former deputy Chattanooga police chiefs Skip Vaughn and Charles Cooke were told they either must retire or “apply for demotions,” their work evaluations stated their job performance was “outstanding.”

The evaluations were prepared and signed by police Chief Freeman Cooper, who also decided just weeks later to eliminate Mr. Cooke’s job.

Chief Cooper said the evaluations were “probably not” true and accurate.

“It is customary after you reach the rank of captain that all of your evaluations are straight A’s (outstanding),” the chief said, explaining that evaluations are used for promotions in the lower ranks, but not those already promoted into administration.

“However, the city code requires those evaluations,” Chief Cooper said.