Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Where free markets fear to tread

Members of Congress who like to subsidize industries that aren’t doing very well often defend subsidies by saying they’re “priming the pump” or “jump-starting the market.” They claim that once consumers are drawn in by prices that are artificially made to seem “competitive,” the subsidies can be withdrawn and those industries can survive on their own with the newly created market.

The trouble is, that theory doesn’t work in the real world.

That is painfully evident in news that some producers of “biofuels” plan to shut down production once their federal tax credit expires. The federal government — meaning you, the taxpayer — has been subsidizing production of “biodiesel,” an alternative fuel used by diesel engines, to the tune of $1 for every single gallon produced. The credit is ending, though, and some producers are halting operations because biodiesel is not profitable when it has to stand on its own merits in the free market.

Dwight Francis, an Oklahoma biodiesel producer who is giving up once the credit ends, told The Associated Press, “By the time you buy the feedstock and the chemicals to produce the fuel, you have more money in it than you get for the fuel without the tax credit.”

So biofuel subsidies — taxpayers’ expense — just wasted lots of money on something consumers didn’t want, and increased federal budget deficits.