HOLLY LEBER: Let’s jump right in. If there’s one woman I’d like to see recognized this year, it’s Gabourey Sidibe in “Precious.” She was astounding. History isn’t in her favor; Best Actress in a Drama hasn’t gone to a first-time performer since 1986 (Marlee Matlin) or a black woman since 1985 (Whoopi Goldberg), but Sidibe’s a front-runner to defy statistics.
CASEY PHILLIPS: A more competitive category, I think, is Best Motion Picture/Drama. I was blown away by four of the five nominees (sorry “Up in the Air”), and while I’d personally love to see “Precious” win here, too, there’s a ton of buzz surrounding “The Hurt Locker,” which would be the first war film to win this category since “Saving Private Ryan” in 1998.
HOLLY: Agreed. However, it’s unlikely Katheryn Bigelow will take Best Director for “Hurt Locker.” Barbra Streisand is the only woman to win that accolade, for “Yentl.” History has a mix of directors winning for bigger vs. smaller films. Jason Reitman could take it for “Up in the Air,” which has a good shot of being overshadowed in its other nominated categories.
CASEY: Speaking of overshadowed, “Hangover” was easily the funniest movie I’ve seen this year (four times), and I’d love to see it take Best Motion Picture/Musical or Comedy. That being said, the Globes have given four of the last eight awards in this category to musicals, which means “Nine” has recent history on its side.
HOLLY: There’s also a history of appreciation for quirky little charmers, which means “(500) Days of Summer” should not be discounted. As for the actors … with a double nod in comedy, Meryl Streep has both statistics and fine performances in her camp. She’ll take it for “Julie & Julia.”