Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

The health reform dilemma

Democrats’ internal stalemate on health care reform is an ominous sign that they are doing precisely what President Obama urged them last week not to do — run for the hills. If House members don’t come to their senses and coalesce around the admittedly weaker Senate bill, which has already passed the Senate’s 60-vote filibuster hurdle and could easily be forwarded to the president for signature, the opportunity to achieve comprehensive health care reform may well die for the foreseeable future.

That would be a grievous setback for the vast majority of America’s hard-working families. Without reform, insurance companies will continue to impose onerous coverage restrictions that already put most families one step away from medical bankruptcy. And the number of uninsured Americans, now more than 48 million, will continue to rise.

Under the present patchwork system of state laws regulating insurers, most states allow insurance companies to deny coverage under private policies for pre-existing conditions, a clause that covers a gamut of chronic but common diseases. They also allow insurers to fix annual and lifetime cost limits on coverage. Reform legislation would reverse these abuses, and address other problems.

Small groups and individuals, for example, now must pay substantially higher, and often unaffordable, rates for coverage comparable to that provided at lower costs for members of large groups. Providers, as well, may charge a range of different prices for the same procedures, depending on a patient’s insurance policy. Drug formularies for covered drugs vary so widely that physician-recommended treatments may be stymied.

Worst of all, medical and insurance costs keep soaring beyond affordable, sensible limits. Annual rate hikes typically are more than double the annual rate of inflation in other price sectors, pushing up health care costs exponentially. Without truly competitive price pressures on the insurance and medical industries and new regulatory restraint that would come through reform, medical costs and insurance will keep soaring.