I understand why Tennessee is mud-wrestling with 39 other states for extra education funds from the feds. State budgets are in tatters, and hey, it’s free money, right?
But there’s no putting a happy spin on the extraordinary legislative session called by the governor and the breakneck pace at which state lawmakers had to leap through federally set hoops to vie for the funds. Whatever merit the legislation may have, the process was a degrading spectacle. It’s hard to recall many times when the states have bowed, scraped and aw-shucksed so fawningly for federal largess.
But surrendering their dignity wasn’t the worst of it. Legislation approved under that sort of deadline pressure, with no time for reflection, is a gold-plated invitation to serious unintended consequences. While some of the reforms adopted in Nashville – namely, use of student test data rather than the usual subjective mush to determine teacher effectiveness – may be worthwhile, the idea that the U.S. Department of Education can dictate sensible local school policies is about as plausible as the phrase, “National Book Award winner Justin Timberlake.”
Let us review what states have gotten so far by filtering hundreds of billions of education dollars through Washington:
Strings attached to every dollar? Check.