Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Railroad fought first Incline for customers in late 1800s

By James L. Douthat

When the Civil War ended and recovery was in progress, more than 60,000 veterans came to Chattanooga during the late 1870s and the early 1880s to show their families the battleground and the view of the valley below from the top of Lookout Mountain. Unfortunately, there was only one road up the mountain. After the removal of the Cherokees in 1839, James A. Whiteside had purchased most of the top and sides of Lookout Mountain for about 12 cents an acre in the Ocoee Land Sales. He had built the road in 1852, retained its rights and now charged tourists $2 per person to use the road. At that time, the finest dinner in the best hotel in town would cost between 25 and 50 cents for a full meal.

Chattanooga businessmen turned covetous eyes toward possible tourist business on the mountain. As a result in 1879, the Johnson Turnpike, now known as the St. Elmo Turnpike, was built to reach the summit. However, when tourists arrived on top, they still had to cross Whiteside property to see the panoramic view they had come to see. Harriet Whiteside imposed a 25-cent toll to cross her property and closed the point to all who did not come by the Owen’s Livery Co. L.J. Sharp, another livery owner, sued the Whitesides, but on Oct. 1, 1883, in U.S. Circuit Court, Judge David Key ruled in the Whitesides’ favor based on the right of a property owner to be selective about who would be allowed on personal property.

The feud continued until 1887 when on March 9 the first of two inclines was completed up the side of the mountain. This incline ran to a hotel built just below the top of the mountain, but constructed to rise above the bluff line, partially blocking the view from the Point. The hotel was on property not owned by the Whitesides but gave access to the same valley view as that of land owned by the Whiteside family.

In the meantime C.E. James and R.L. and Ed Watkins applied for a charter from the state to build a Broad Gauge Railroad up the side of the mountain. The route of the Broad Gauge was to terminate on top near the Point, unlike the Incline, which required a short walk to the view. An advertisement ran in the Chattanooga newspaper calling for 500 workers to be paid $1 per day. Workers with a team of horses would be paid $2.50 per day. Immediately, a strike was called by the Knights of Labor, seeking 50 cents more per day. Railroad president Watkins offered workers $1.10, but many still refused to accept. The next day Watkins came out with a pick in his hand to do the work himself and the strike was over. Once work started, the tracks were laid in swift order, and on May 27, 1888, the rail line officially opened, a few days after completion of the Point Hotel and the same day that the Lookout Mountain Land Co. put parcels of land up for sale.