Officials in Florida have learned the hard way that they cannot break basic laws of economics without paying a terrible price.
State Farm’s Florida subsidiary tried to raise its property insurance rates. The company needed the increase to protect against crippling losses — and to ensure it could pay policyholders — if one or a series of hurricanes hit Florida and caused huge financial losses.
But state officials felt they knew better than State Farm about how much the company should charge. So regulators substituted their own judgment in the matter and said State Farm would have to settle for a rate increase that the state considered more reasonable. Officials seemed to think that would “protect” State Farm’s policyholders.
But it didn’t work out that way. Given the enormous risk of damage from hurricanes, State Farm realized it could not maintain coverage for all of its policyholders at the rates dictated by the state. So not long ago, the company began sending notices to 125,000 policyholders stating that their property insurance policies would not be renewed after their current coverage period ends. Most of those affected live along the coast, where the risk of storm damage is greatest.
State Farm’s withdrawal raises some questions for those who think companies are “gouging” and “greedy” when they raise prices: If State Farm could make even a modest profit by continuing to cover those 125,000 policyholders, wouldn’t it do so? Would it give up all those customers unless it really believed it would lose money by keeping them?