Skip to main content
Monday, November 9, 2026Nov 9

County needs sharper rules

County attorney Rheubin Taylor asserted Tuesday that it was wrong to release as public records the e-mails on a county computer that nailed a county employee for routinely working on his lucrative private business on the taxpayers’ time. Taylor’s shallow opinion strikes us as a wrong-headed slap to taxpayers. The county attorney, and county government’s elected leaders, should be much more interested in seeing that county employees are doing their jobs properly than in protecting miscreant employees from public scrutiny for violating county work rules.

Under Taylor’s opinion, this newspaper’s reporter, Dan Whisenhunt, would not have been able to obtain the e-mails that confirmed Alan Knowles’ violation of county policies. Knowles, a county Public Works supervisor and son of County Clerk Bill Knowles, was busy earning $157,345 over the past three years by working on his private business, in part, on county time and county computers.

Knowles finally received a mere five-day suspension from embarrassed county officials after Whisenhunt’s stories revealed his work for his for-profit business – Dove Ministries, a concert-organizing service – while he was being paid by county taxpayers.

Taylor’s interpretation of the state Open Records Act would have prevented those stories. His view seems crimped in the extreme. His opinion, moreover, springs from a 2005 state appeals court ruling that is itself ambiguous. That opinion was cited by Elisha Hodge, the state’s Open Records Office counsel, as the basis for interpreting the law on public records to say that public employees’ purely personal e-mails (though not Knowles’ e-mails specifically) are generally exempt from disclosure under the state’s Open Records Act.

She and Taylor pointed out that a 2005 appeals court opinion (Ed Brennan v. Giles County Board of Education) found that personal e-mails did not meet the definition of public records if they were not “made or received pursuant to law or ordinance (emphasis ours) or in connection with the transaction of official business.”