The consumption of alcohol – beer, wine and distilled spirits or liquor – is a habit that prompts heated discussion. On the one hand, studies show that moderate drinkers tend to have better health and live longer than those who do not drink or who are heavy drinkers. On the other, alcohol abuse is one of the leading causes of preventable death in the United States and it contributes heavily to the country’s incidence of disease, vehicular accidents, injuries and crimes.
The challenge in a free society is to find a way to discourage those who drink to excess without infringing on the rights of those who do not drink or who drink in moderation. Punitive measures – fines, loss of driver’s licenses and incarceration – deter excessive drinking in some cases, but not all. Educational programs and in-house and outpatient treatment regimens have a similarly mixed record. A new study, published in the American Journal of Public Health, suggests another option is available.
It suggests that an effective way to significantly reduce abuse is to make drinking more expensive by doubling current state taxes on alcohol. Doing so would add about 50 cents to the cost of a bottle of wine or six-pack and a bit more to a bottle of liquor. The exact increase would vary from state to state, but the overall affect is consistent. A tax increase would save lives, reduce death and injury rates and reduce health costs across the board.
There’s considerable evidence available to support the study’s conclusion. Recent increases in the tax on cigarettes and other tobacco items – another product often abused – has prompted declines in smoking rates, even among heavy smokers. There’s reason to believe that similar reductions would occur among drinkers if alcohol taxes were raised. If so, the numbers are attention-grabbers.
Doubling state taxes on alcohol, according to the study, could cut alcohol-related deaths by 35 percent, reduce fatal car crashes by 11 percent and lower the rates of sexually transmitted disease by 6 percent. In addition, researchers estimate that higher taxes on alcohol could lead to 2 percent less violence and 1.4 percent less crime. The improvements would not be immediate, but occur incrementally as the cumulative effect of increased prices affected the buying habits of those who drink.