Chattanooga City Judge Russell Bean charged Thursday evening that Mayor Ron Littlefield’s talk about moving City Court is part of a “vendetta” against City Judge Sherry Paty over last year’s Pet Company case.
“This allegedly stems from the case between McKamey Animal Shelter and a local Pet Company where McKamey lost the case,” Bean said in an e-mail Thursday night. “They allegedly feel that Judge Paty ruled wrongly and they are upset. Allegedly they have banned (sic) together and are after Judge Paty and want to embarrass her and make her judicial life miserable.”
In June, McKamey staff took 82 animals from the Pet Company at Hamilton Place after the store was cited for animal cruelty. Paty declared a mistrial in July after Littlefield wrote asking her to make the Pet Company reimburse McKamey for its costs. Paty called the communication “improper” and “unethical.” A special judge dismissed the case in October.
McKamey Executive Director Karen Walsh said in an e-mailed statement Thursday night that she was “astonished by Judge Bean’s evaluation of this situation.”
“All of the officers at McKamey animal center including myself have a good working relationship with Judge Paty and have great respect for the judicial system,” Walsh wrote. “We do not feel that we lost the case against the Pet Company but rather that it was ended without a verdict. We have cases in Judge Paty’s courtroom every Thursday and will continue to do so wherever the court is held.”