Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Health reform goes to court

The Supreme Court’s decision Monday to review the constitutionality of the 2010 health care reform act, and its linchpin mandate requiring most Americans to purchase health insurance, puts in motion a trial of one of the nation’s most heavily freighted political controversies in decades, and will do so amid a heated presidential election. Whether that’s fair or good for the nation remains to be seen. Yet regardless of the court’s ruling, it has already become clear that the need for reform is too huge, too critical and too compelling to be stifled by inaction. If the court’s controlling conservative judges are at all attuned to justice for the nation’s needs, they will rise above political currents and affirm the federal government’s role in devising and marshaling systemic health care reform.

The court has promised to hear selected appeals on the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act next March, and to deliver an opinion by June. That will place its ruling in the middle of a super-heated presidential campaign which may turn on the court’s decision in this historic case.

Ironically, it’s impossible to predict the impact of the court’s decision, whatever it decides. At first glance, it would seem that the Obama administration would benefit from a decision affirming the constitutionality of the act, and its central provision requiring Americans to purchase health insurance (largely with the broad federal wage-indexed subsidies for most families).

Yet affirmation of the reform act might energize opponents to elect a presidential candidate and representatives who promise to repeal the reform act. Similarly, a court decision to overturn the act might rally its supporters around the administration to advance the hope of passing a bona fide public plan as a voluntary option for Americans to private insurance. Such a plan, say, an expansion of Medicare for all who elect to pay a fair, flat-rate premium to join a full-benefit plan with no pre-existing conditions, would benefit most families. It certainly would be cheaper and far superior to private insurance companies that cherry-pick the healthy, deny people with pre-existing conditions, and spend outrageous shares of premium revenue on executives’ breath-taking salaries and stock options.

It is these insurance industry tactics that create the nation’s unaffordably high rates of uninsured and of under-insured Americans. More than 50 million Americans are uninsured. An equal number are under-insured who, like the uninsured, are also vulnerable to bankruptcies due to outrageous medical costs — now the largest segment of the nation’s bankruptcies.