Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Judge accused of bias called defense ‘sloppy’

chattanooga-judge-accused-of-bias-called-defense
chattanooga-judge-accused-of-bias-called-defense
photo Ardena Garth

Details in a recent transcript show a local Criminal Court judge is frustrated with what he perceives as “sloppy” legal work by some public defender’s attorneys and he wants it to end.

The Aug. 14 hearing before Hamilton County Judge Barry Steelman led District Public Defender Ardena Garth to request that the judge recuse himself or reassign her office’s cases out of concern that he is biased.

The hearing involved allegations by criminal defendant Frederick Anderson, who was found guilty on Sept. 23, 2011, by a jury on nine counts connected to an armed kidnapping and assault. Anderson claimed in last week’s hearing that both Steelman and his public defender, Mary Ann Green, were biased against him.