Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Disbarred Georgia judge files lawsuit, claiming authorities tried to destroy his career

disbarred-georgia-judge-files-lawsuit-claiming-aut
disbarred-georgia-judge-files-lawsuit-claiming-aut
photo Magistrate Judge Anthony Peters listens during an April hearing where the state sought to remove him from bench for erratic behavior. The Tuesday Georgia Supreme Court’s unanimous opinion barred Peters from ever holding another judicial office in Georgia.

A former Georgia judge who was disbarred for smoking pot has filed a lawsuit against his supervisor and the sheriff, claiming they conspired to destroy his career.

Anthony Peters, who filed the federal lawsuit in North Georgia, claims his boss, former Catoosa County Chief Magistrate Donald “Sonny” Caldwell, tried to demote him after learning he planned to run for chief magistrate, then devised a plan with Sheriff Phil Summers to interfere with his political ambitions.

In 2010, Caldwell told Peters that he was being changed to a 3-to-11 p.m. shift, typically the responsibility of an on-call judge, then ordered Peters to leave the courthouse and had him arrested when he refused, the lawsuit states.

“They conspired to put him out of office,” said Peters’ attorney James Satcher Jr.

After the incident, Peters wasn’t allowed to return to work.