One of Hurricane Katrina’s many legacies is the belief that the Federal Emergency Management Agency failed to do its duty in the wake of the natural disaster responsible for nearly 1,800 deaths and over $100 billion in property damage. There is some truth in that view, but FEMA has come a long way since 2005. The retooled agency has responded commendably to the destruction and displacement wrought by Superstorm Sandy. The current effort, not the Katrina debacle, should be how the agency is judged in the future.
By at least one measure, Sandy posed more complex and widespread problems for FEMA than Katrina. The latter caused far more damage — about twice the current estimate for Sandy — but this week’s storm affected millions more people because it struck one of the most densely populated regions of the nation. FEMA was up to the task. It moved into position ahead of the storm, quickly provided assistance where needed and helped to coordinate state and local assistance efforts. That’s exactly what the agency is supposed to do.
Its dereliction of duty in 2005 was tied to politics. FEMA was streamlined and strengthened during the Clinton administration. It was emasculated during the George W. Bush administration, which whacked agency funds in its short-sighted campaign to cut federal spending. That was a terrible idea. When FEMA tried to respond to Katrina, the lack of funds and concomitant reduction in trained personnel left it unable to react quickly, to co-ordinate relief efforts across several states and to provide effective short and long-term relief.
The Bush faithful, of course, preferred to put the blame elsewhere, but even the president’s claim that then agency director Michael D. Brown was doing “a heckuva job” could not obscure the obvious. FEMA was poorly led and unable to do its job. The Bush White House and its coterie of conservative budget-cutters — not the agency itself — rightly should bear the blame for the Katrina failure.
There’s no hint of failure this time. FEMA has done its job, thanks to the Obama administration’s insistence that it be funded adequately. Agency teams were in place to help with planning before Sandy barreled ashore. Its workers began providing assistance and coordination as soon as safety officials gave them the all-clear after the storm. And agency teams continue to assist in clean-up efforts even as they arrange loans and other aid so states, cities, businesses and individuals can begin the arduous return to normalcy.