He was America’s most honored general, and for good reason. From West Point to Princeton, the classroom to the battlefield, theory to practice, David Petraeus had studied. And then acted on what he’d learned. He literally wrote the book on counter-insurgency warfare, or at least oversaw its compilation and culmination.
In the Army’s and the country’s hour of desperation in Iraq, others were ready to accept failure there and call it statesmanship. Master strategist Joe Biden was advocating that we just leave — and let that bloody mess of a country vivisect itself into three ethnic parts.
But this four-star general had a different idea. It was called “the surge,” an infusion, not only of new troops, but a new attitude — working with Iraqis on the ground, building alliances, recruiting new forces who would fight for a better, more stable and democratic future for their reunited country.
Naturally, the general was hooted down by those who knew only that they knew better.
In a phrase that will always stay with her, Hillary Clinton, the senator from New York who would go on to become secretary of state, said it would take “a willing suspension of disbelief” to believe this upstart general. The senator from Illinois, a political newcomer named Barack Obama, hastened to agree. He, too, scoffed at this surge the general was proposing.