Electric car maker Tesla Motors is fighting a somewhat quixotic battle with state governments over the right to sell cars direct to the public. This may seem surprising in the age of Internet shopping, but the U.S. auto industry still operates under rules laid down a hundred years ago.
You can buy direct at the Apple Store, order corrective lenses at 1-800-Contacts, book a flight on Southwest Airlines, and fritter away your retirement savings with any number of discount brokers for $8 per trade. But you can’t buy a new car without going through a franchised dealer, even if you don’t need a test drive.
The system of franchised auto dealerships traces back to the early 20th century. Since that time, quite a few things have changed. But how you buy a car is essentially unchanged since your grandparents bought their Model T.
Most states have laws requiring auto manufacturers to sell their products through franchised dealers. While the roots of this archaic system can be traced to the days of Henry Ford, the Internet age clearly renders this arrangement anachronistic and costly to consumers.
And few buyers fully appreciate the additional cost imposed by this de-facto oligopoly. A recent study by the U.S. Department of Justice estimates that consumers pay 6 percent to 9 percent more for a new vehicle thanks to state protection of dealers.
