Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Tennessee open records advocates fear impact of court ruling

tennessee-open-records-advocates-fear-impact-of
tennessee-open-records-advocates-fear-impact-of

NASHVILLE – Transparency advocates are warning about the ramifications of a recent Tennessee appeals court ruling that “high government officials” can keep documents secret if they deem them part of their decision-making process.

The court upheld a lower court’s ruling that then-Gov. Phil Bredesen’s administration was justified in denying the release of records on the basis that they were part of the “deliberative process” about how to deal with demonstrators encamped in the state Capitol in 2005 to protest cuts to TennCare, the state’s expanded Medicaid program.

The unanimous opinion written by Judge Richard Dinkins, whom Bredesen appointed in 2008, endorsed the argument that “advice high governmental officials receive be protected from disclosure” because those officials need to be able to speak freely and confidentially with trusted advisers.

Ben Cunningham, the founder and president of the Nashville Tea Party, called the ruling “an assault on open government (that) will invite abuse of power by any government official arrogant enough to consider themselves a ‘high government official.'”

While previous legal rulings had acknowledged that an exemption might exist for records deemed deliberative, the Oct. 29 ruling for the first time explicitly applied it to a specific case, Tennessee Press Association attorney Rick Hollow said.