Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Fare Exchange: Recipes that college boys love and tomato pie

fare-exchange-recipes-college-boys-love-and-tomato
fare-exchange-recipes-college-boys-love-and-tomato

TO REACH USFare Exchange is a longtime meeting place for people who love to cook and love to eat. We welcome both your recipes and your requests. Be sure to include precise instructions for every recipe you send.• Mailing address: Jane Henegar, 913 Mount Olive Road, Lookout Mountain, GA 30750• E-mail: chattfare@gmail.com• Fax: 423-668-5092

Good morning, readers. We have a new entry in the nostalgic request category: recipes from Shapiro’s. Secondly, we are looking for Italian recipes for preparing fish entrees.

Kim from East Brainerd wrote, “I was looking on the web for the potato salad recipe from the old Shapiro restaurant on Cherry Street and I came across another request in Fare Exchange. Lew of Signal Mountain requested the 1960s version of the recipe on April 28, 2010. Did anyone respond? Do you happen to have the recipe?

“There was a newspaper clipping on the wall at the later Shapiro’s in St. Elmo, featuring the original Mr. Shapiro and his recipe, but that restaurant has since closed. I made the potato salad from the recipe years ago and it was great, but I have lost my handwritten copy. Could you help? Also, do you have any additional recipes from Shapiro’s? My husband and I miss them. We loved their hot dogs, slaw, potato salad, half-cured pickles and Coca-Cola cake.”

Shapiro’s was probably the town’s earliest deli, and I remember its central counter with an amazing display of deli meats and cheeses to be sliced as you waited. The aroma of their special pickles and pastrami filled the air. Shapiro’s just may have introduced the bagel to Chattanooga, too.