A recent city audit found that Chattanooga City Court has overcharged residents with outstanding traffic tickets or water quality bills by tacking on the collection agency’s fee to the cost of the bill.
The practice violates current city ordinance and also resulted in the collection agency, Nationwide Recovery Services, overcharging City Court for its collection fees by $36,000 in 2013, the audit shows.
The city’s Internal Audit office also found other negligence in City Court practices in which NRS applied an incorrect commission rate to residents’ delinquent water quality fees. The audit also found the process to close a customer’s account leaves room “for fraud and loss of revenue.”
But City Auditor Stan Sewell said he believes the mistakes were made in good faith and no one intentionally financially gained from the errors.
In part, the oversight was because clerks were unaware of the ordinance that states any collection fees cannot be added to a defendant’s judgment cost, Sewell said. This means when a clerk sent a judgment to the collection agency, he or she automatically tacked on the agency’s 17 percent fee. Then when the agency billed the court for their services, it billed a fee on top of the new total, overcharging the court.

