Given the narrowness of Monday’s Supreme Court decision on Obamacare’s contraception mandate, look for the words “closely held corporations” to be addressed in the near future in a court near you.
The 5-4 decision said closely held corporations such as the family-owned Hobby Lobby arts and crafts store and the Conestoga Wood Specialties company, in spite of being for-profit businesses, do not have to provide certain abortion-inducing contraceptives to their employees under the Affordable Care Act because to do so would violate their deeply held religious beliefs granted by the First Amendment and other laws.
The ruling thankfully affirms that family businesses may still make certain decisions about issues they believe to be injurious — in this case, a decision that “substantially burdens the exercise of religion” — without the threat of crippling fines. So don’t expect Walmart or General Motors, for instance, to make — or be granted relief in — such a case.
But dissenting justices say the decision could allow other private businesses to challenge the law on religious reasons if they object to other services such as vaccinations, blood transfusions or medical devices derived from pigs. And the question of exactly what “closely held corporations” are will certainly be tested if the next plaintiff is not so plainly “closely held” as Hobby Lobby and Conestoga.
Justice Samuel Alito, writing for the majority in Burwell (formerly Sebelius) v. Hobby Lobby, said the contraception mandate not only violated the First Amendment but also the 1993 Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA), which states the federal government can only force people to violate their religious beliefs “if the government has an extremely important reason” for doing so “and the government cannot accomplish its goal in any less restrictive way.”
