It only took a Hamilton County juvenile magistrate 10 minutes to decide that a Chattanooga couple whose newborn was taken from them in the hospital should get their daughter back.
Still, Magistrate Chris Gott said he didn’t have the authority to override a court in another state. Ultimately, the family’s fate will have to be decided by a higher court.
“If this had been a hearing in [Chattanooga], she would have gone home,” Will McBryar said the judge told him in the closed hearing Wednesday.
Now Will and Diana McBryar, who were the focus of a Times Free Press investigation last Sunday and have been fighting for custody of their daughter, Tobi, since September, will have to wait even longer. It has already been more than six months since their newborn was taken from Erlanger East after a Georgia child welfare social worker determined that, while the child had not been abused, future abuse was possible because she believed the parents were mentally ill.
If the couple takes the case to a higher court in Georgia, it could be more than a year before they are reunited with their daughter. If they file an appeal in Tennessee the result would be quicker, but more unpredictable. Keeping the case in Tennessee means there will be a whole new review of the circumstances.
