NEW YORK (AP) – An apartment house where only high-paying tenants can use the gym may be illegally discriminating, city officials said this week amid debate over luxury buildings that provide fewer amenities – or even separate doors – for residents of affordable apartments.
The company that owns the building on Manhattan’s Upper West Side said Friday it was trying to work out a solution to the dispute. Since the gym was added last year, it’s been free to market-rate residents but off-limits to rent-stabilized tenants.
After the tenants’ association president complained that it smacked of second-class citizenship, the city Human Rights Commission said in a notice Thursday that there was enough evidence of age discrimination to merit an administrative trial. The rent-regulated tenants at the Stonehenge Village complex are largely over 65, while market-rate tenants aren’t, according to the complaint.
The tenant president, Jean Green Dorsey, said she’s hopeful the landlord will now let rent-stabilized tenants pay a reasonable fee to use the gym and have it continue to be free for their higher-rent neighbors. Green Dorsey said tenants previously offered to do that but were rebuffed, spurring her complaint.
“You really shouldn’t have to do all this to live a happy life,” said Green Dorsey, 75, who has lived in the complex since 1972.
