Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

NYC board: High-rent-tenants-only gym may be discriminatory

FILE- In this Aug. 5, 2014 file photo, Jean Green Dorsey walks outside the building on New York City’s Upper West Side where she has lived since 1972. Green Dorsey’s apartment house where only high-paying tenants can use the gym may be illegally discriminating, city human rights officials said this week, weighing in on a ban that encapsulated a debate over luxury buildings with separate amenities, or even doors, for residents of affordable apartments. (AP Photo/Bebeto Matthews, File)
FILE- In this Aug. 5, 2014 file photo, Jean Green Dorsey walks outside the building on New York City’s Upper West Side where she has lived since 1972. Green Dorsey’s apartment house where only high-paying tenants can use the gym may be illegally discriminating, city human rights officials said this week, weighing in on a ban that encapsulated a debate over luxury buildings with separate amenities, or even doors, for residents of affordable apartments. (AP Photo/Bebeto Matthews, File)

NEW YORK (AP) – An apartment house where only high-paying tenants can use the gym may be illegally discriminating, city officials said this week amid debate over luxury buildings that provide fewer amenities – or even separate doors – for residents of affordable apartments.

The company that owns the building on Manhattan’s Upper West Side said Friday it was trying to work out a solution to the dispute. Since the gym was added last year, it’s been free to market-rate residents but off-limits to rent-stabilized tenants.

After the tenants’ association president complained that it smacked of second-class citizenship, the city Human Rights Commission said in a notice Thursday that there was enough evidence of age discrimination to merit an administrative trial. The rent-regulated tenants at the Stonehenge Village complex are largely over 65, while market-rate tenants aren’t, according to the complaint.

The tenant president, Jean Green Dorsey, said she’s hopeful the landlord will now let rent-stabilized tenants pay a reasonable fee to use the gym and have it continue to be free for their higher-rent neighbors. Green Dorsey said tenants previously offered to do that but were rebuffed, spurring her complaint.

“You really shouldn’t have to do all this to live a happy life,” said Green Dorsey, 75, who has lived in the complex since 1972.