The education world was rocked last week when a eight of the 10 Atlanta educators convicted of racketeering in one of the nation’s largest public school cheating scandals were sentenced to prison terms of up to seven years.
The educators had refused to take sentencing deals that were predicated on their acceptance of responsibility and a waiver of their right to appeal.
In Atlanta after the sentencing, news shows rocked with questions of how much mercy should be due to these teachers with otherwise good records. Another question that had countless responses but no answers was what kind of justice is due the students, most of whom are minorities, whose wrongly inflated test scores hid academic shortcomings.
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution opined: “It would be a mistake to cast the [Atlanta public schools] cheating scandal as a saga of failed character, although the trial revealed plenty of moral lapses and self-serving decisions. The scandal also points to failed education policy, and the verdict is not yet in on whether that’s been addressed.”
We beg to differ. It is a saga of failed character.
