Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

After historic arguments, Supreme Court to rule on same-sex marriage

Washington attorney Douglas Hallward-Driemeier, speaks with reporters outside the Supreme Court in Washington, Tuesday, April 28, 2015, after arguing arguing that states must recognize same-sex marriages performed elsewhere before the court.
Washington attorney Douglas Hallward-Driemeier, speaks with reporters outside the Supreme Court in Washington, Tuesday, April 28, 2015, after arguing arguing that states must recognize same-sex marriages performed elsewhere before the court.

WASHINGTON — Pivotal Justice Anthony Kennedy, whose vote could decide the same-sex marriage issue for the nation, did not tip his hand Tuesday in historic arguments at the Supreme Court. But Kennedy’s record on the issue could give encouragement to gay and lesbian couples.

As advocates and protesters demonstrated outside, the author of the court’s three prior gay rights rulings talked about the touchstones of dignity and concern for children in same-sex households that drove his favorable earlier opinions.

Local reaction

Local reaction to Supreme Court’s opening arguments on gay marriage: Tennessee Attorney General Herbert H. Slatery III: “Associate Solicitor General Counsel Joe Whalen did an excellent job arguing the case. He represented well the state of Tennessee, poised and articulate as he was when he successfully argued the case before the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals. Our hope is that the Court affirms the Sixth Circuit and will leave it to the states to decide what marriages to recognize. This has been the longstanding province of the states and our position is that it should stay that way. Let the citizens of the state vote and decide such important issues. As the Sixth Circuit said, decide by democracy rather than litigation.” David Fowler, president of the Family Action Council of Tennessee: “The oral arguments today on marriage and the decision that will ultimately flow from them will have the potential to forever change the way we understand the Constitution and the principle of federalism and states’ rights. Since our nation’s founding, states have defined marriage as a man and a woman, and if the Supreme Court is going to alter this understanding of states’ rights, then they owe it to the millions of Americans who have voted to define marriage as one man and one woman to tell us what that new definition of marriage is. And they owe it to the judges and the state legislative bodies, because they will be left to grapple with the arguments for polygamous and polyandrous marriages that are sure to come.” Colton Griffin, LGBT Caucus Vice Chair, Democratic Party of Georgia: “I, and many others, hold hope that the Supreme Court will decide in favor of equality, opportunity and progress. We are witnessing the shaping of a better nation.”

Read more

* Marriage equality is the right decision * Gay marriage decision now up to court

But he also worried about changing the definition of marriage from the union of a man and a woman, a meaning that he said has existed for “millennia-plus time.”