A federal court jury deliberated for five hours Friday trying to determine if a school nurse at Apison Elementary violated the constitutional rights of a former 5-year-old student by performing “body checks” on the young girl without the permission of her mother or pediatrician.
The jury announced it had reached a unanimous verdict in favor of the Hamilton County Department of Education, determining that the mother and her attorney failed to provide sufficient evidence during the four-day trial to convince them that the school system should be held liable for the searches. But when each juror answered before the court if they agreed with the verdict, two out of the 12 said “no.”
“This is a rarity,” said U.S. District Judge Curtis Collier.
The jury exited the courtroom to continue deliberations and returned 10 minutes later saying they now had a unanimous verdict, though some jurors were slow to affirm “yes” when called upon for an answer.
In 2012, a school nurse did body checks on a student who has cerebral palsy and uses a wheelchair. The searches were conducted because she contracted congenital herpes simplex at birth, which shows up in a series of small blisters on her right heel.
