Skip to main content
Friday, November 20, 2026Nov 20

The Duality of Dixie: This century’s civil war

Southerners have conflicting feelings about their history.
Southerners have conflicting feelings about their history.

For this is still a place where you must have either been born, or have people there, to feel it is your native ground. Natives will tell you this. They are proud to be Americans, but they are also proud to be Virginians, South Carolinians, Tennesseans, Mississippians and Texans. But they are conscious of another loyalty too, one that transcends the usual ties of national patriotism and state pride. It is a loyalty to a place where habits are strong and memories are long. If those memories could speak, they would tell stories of a region powerfully shaped by its history and determined to pass it on to future generations.

Southern stalwarts

“[Southerners] are … tough, stubborn, compassionate, driven, stylish, eccentric, hard workers, strong in the face of adversity, and gracious. We have attitude, but we also possess great diplomacy and tact … with a strong sense of belonging and community. I always say, ‘Southern by the grace of God.’” — René Doggett Berrien, born in Chattanooga, now living in New Jersey“[The South is a] state of mind, not a flag.” — Wes Phelps, Chattanooga“I may not agree with all of the political and religious affiliations of my neighbors, [but] we are still a community, and we band together to protect our little slice of the countryside. The South is proud and strong, and the history is rich and interesting. … I am proud of my heritage, and will always be.” — Woody Merrell, born in Reliance, Tenn., now living in St. George, Utah“I’m very proud to be a Southerner. I think the issues we see today stem from the fact that we are very deeply rooted in our traditions. We stop when a funeral goes by because … that is just what you do. [But we are also] holding on to some traditions that may not be helpful. … Some Southerners take pride in the tradition of ignorance.” — Jake Redish, Chattanooga“I’m proud to be from the South! I think I’m blessed to be born and live here.” — Dan Davis, Flintstone, Ga.“[Being Southern means] letting somebody over on the interstate, saying ‘Excuse me’ when you bump into someone, saying ‘Thank you and have a nice day’ when you go through the drive-through, and drinking tea even sweeter than your manners.” — Amber Smith, Chattanooga“There are plenty of things to dislike about the South, but I’m certainly still a proud Southerner. We have great literature, epic folk music traditions, fine spirits, world-renowned hospitality and the best damn food.” — Chris Kerys Dolan, Chattanooga“I’ve lived in the South most of my life and I can honestly say that it is the only place that feels like home. … Every home has flaws. The floors creak, the doors don’t hang right, or the faucets leak. You deal with them, fix what you can when you can, and work around what you haven’t gotten to yet. Well, the South’s like that, too. … Yes, we have made some egregious mistakes in the past. … You cannot change the past, but you can learn from it … [and] you only learn from it by confronting it.”— Julia Buckner, Chattanooga“I love where I live, and I detest the rednecks and KKK that like the rebel [flag]! Wish they would just get over it sooner [rather] than later!!!” — Barbara Sitten, East Ridge“I am rather uncertain about all the negative publicity we Southerners have been getting since that horrible shooting in South Carolina. Why is that? Because the killer waved a Confederate flag? … My witness of what happened here in the South just after the incident was of true, deep sorrow and shock at what had just taken place. Then — in true Southern form — I saw people of all races, religions, and social standings coming together. We cried together, prayed together, stood together. No one from here that I encountered ever mentioned color or race, only heartbreak and deepest sympathy. This is the South I know.” — Teresa Ketterer Norton, Chattanooga

There are many Southerners still caught in the grip of a civil war, only there are no battle lines to draw, and victor and vanquished are one and the same.

It is an internal struggle, a clash between bone-deep pride in the South’s distinctive cultural heritage and a patchwork quilt of shame implicating them in a history of racial injustice, narrow-mindedness and a rogues gallery of other atrocities.

The South is the birthplace of country music and rock’n’roll, but many still hear the echoing, not-quite-faded chorus of police attack dogs and fire hoses. Far more Southerners enlist in the U.S. military than any other region, but its back roads are dotted with proudly fluttering flags of rebellion.