Skip to main content
Saturday, November 14, 2026Nov 14

Supreme Court considers impact of disability law on police

This handout photo provided by Patricia C. Sheehan, taken Dec. 25, 2013, shows Teresa Sheehan. The Supreme Court on March 23, 2015, will consider whether police must take special precautions when trying to arrest a person who is mentally ill. The case centers on Teresa Sheehan. Police forced their way into her room at a group home after she threatened her social worker and when she came at them with a knife, officers shot her five times. Lawyers for Sheehan say the Americans With Disabilities Act requires police to make reasonable accommodations when arresting people who have mental or physical disabilities.  (AP Photo/Patricia C. Sheehan)
This handout photo provided by Patricia C. Sheehan, taken Dec. 25, 2013, shows Teresa Sheehan. The Supreme Court on March 23, 2015, will consider whether police must take special precautions when trying to arrest a person who is mentally ill. The case centers on Teresa Sheehan. Police forced their way into her room at a group home after she threatened her social worker and when she came at them with a knife, officers shot her five times. Lawyers for Sheehan say the Americans With Disabilities Act requires police to make reasonable accommodations when arresting people who have mental or physical disabilities. (AP Photo/Patricia C. Sheehan)

WASHINGTON (AP) – The Supreme Court is considering whether the Americans With Disabilities Act requires police to take special precautions when trying to arrest armed and violent suspects who are mentally ill.

The justices hear arguments on Monday in a dispute over how San Francisco police dealt with a woman with schizophrenia who had threatened to kill her social worker. Police forced their way into Teresa Sheehan’s room at a group home and then shot her after she came at them with a knife.

Lawyers for Sheehan say police must make reasonable accommodations when arresting people with mental or physical disabilities. They say police could have used less aggressive tactics to avoid a violent confrontation.

City officials say Sheehan posed an immediate safety threat and police had no duty to change their response.