Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Judge orders risk review of sex offenders in civil program

FILE - This April 19, 2010 file photo shows the Moose Lake, Minn., facility for sex offenders that was likened by offenders housed there in a lawsuit to a second prison sentence rather than the treatment program is was designed to be. Minnesota is awaiting word from a federal judge on how it must change its restrictive program for sex offenders, a long-awaited step for more than 700 offenders housed in Minnesota's two facilities. (AP Photo/Martiga Lohn, File)
FILE - This April 19, 2010 file photo shows the Moose Lake, Minn., facility for sex offenders that was likened by offenders housed there in a lawsuit to a second prison sentence rather than the treatment program is was designed to be. Minnesota is awaiting word from a federal judge on how it must change its restrictive program for sex offenders, a long-awaited step for more than 700 offenders housed in Minnesota's two facilities. (AP Photo/Martiga Lohn, File)

ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) – A federal judge ordered a risk assessment Thursday of all sex offenders in Minnesota’s restrictive civil confinement program to determine which can be put on a pathway for release.

Judge Donovan Frank laid out what he says must be done to fix problems with indefinite detentions that he earlier ruled unconstitutional.

His decision undoubtedly sets the stage for an appeal by state officials and lawyers, who argue they are properly holding more than 700 offenders they consider too risky to free.

Frank’s ruling sets a swift timetable for state officials to carry out the review and start transferring lower-risk offenders. He says he could order further changes later. Frank also said if the state doesn’t comply, he reserves the right to stop new commitments and hold the state in contempt.

“Given the (program’s) decades-long history of operating an unconstitutional civil commitment program, the deeply systemic nature of the problems plaguing this state’s sex offender civil commitment scheme, and the minimal progress made toward remedying any constitutional infirmities since the start of this litigation four years ago, the court concludes that it must exercise its broad remedial power,” Frank said.